Resources

3–5 Reviews a Month: The Secret to Sustaining a Strong Online Reputation

May 4, 2025
Freddie Peyerl
Post by
Freddie Peyerl

In the competitive world of senior living, first impressions matter — and more often than not, that first impression happens online. Whether families are searching for independent living, assisted living, or memory care options, they’re likely beginning their journey with a quick Google search.

And what do they see? Your reviews.

The quantity, quality, and recency of your Google Reviews don’t just influence where your community appears in search results — they can be the deciding factor in whether a family chooses to take the next step and schedule a tour.

So how many reviews do you really need? At Quiltt, we recommend a simple but powerful goal: 3 to 5 new reviews every month. Let’s break down why that steady pace matters, and how to make it part of your routine.

Why Ongoing Reviews Matter More Than a High Total

It’s easy to think that once you’ve collected a solid number of Google Reviews, your work is done. But Google’s algorithm — and the behavior of prospective families — tells a different story.

Google Prioritizes Freshness

Search engines reward activity. A community that gets regular reviews appears more current, more active, and more relevant to potential residents.

If your most recent review is from six months ago, Google might assume your business is less engaged or less trustworthy — even if your overall star rating is excellent.

Families Want to Know What’s Happening Now

Older reviews feel outdated. Senior living decisions are emotional and time-sensitive. Families want to know what current residents and families are experiencing today, not last year.

Newer reviews:

  • Build trust quickly
  • Reflect recent leadership, programming, and care changes
  • Show that your community is thriving in real-time

The Power of 3–5 Reviews per Month

You don’t need to chase hundreds of reviews overnight. A slow, steady, and consistent stream of reviews actually performs better than a large one-time surge.

Why 3–5 Is the Sweet Spot

  • It’s manageable – Most teams can comfortably ask for 1–2 reviews per week
  • It’s effective – That pace ensures your reviews stay fresh and SEO-friendly
  • It’s sustainable – You avoid suspicious spikes that may appear inauthentic

Think of reviews like watering a plant. Regular attention leads to long-term growth. Ignore it for too long, and the effects become obvious.

How to Consistently Collect New Reviews

Making review collection a habit doesn’t require a major overhaul. It simply takes consistency, timing, and a little encouragement.

Here Are Some Proven Strategies:

1. Identify "Review Moments"

Look for natural, positive touchpoints with residents or families, such as:

  • After a successful tour or event
  • When a resident moves in
  • Following a compliment in conversation or email

2. Make It Easy

Provide direct links to your Google Review page. You can add them to:

  • Email signatures
  • Event follow-up messages
  • Printed thank-you cards with QR codes

3. Empower Your Team

Train your front desk staff, life enrichment team, and sales counselors to recognize and act on review opportunities.

Make it part of the culture: “When someone compliments us, it’s a great time to ask them to share it online.”

4. Use Technology to Help

Platforms like Quiltt make it easy to identify happy families and guide them to leave reviews with a gentle, personalized nudge — without the awkward ask.

What About Negative Reviews?

When you increase your review volume, it’s possible you’ll eventually get a negative review. That’s okay. In fact, a mix of feedback can make your profile look more credible.

What matters is how you respond:

  • Acknowledge the feedback professionally
  • Show a willingness to improve
  • Take the conversation offline when appropriate

Handled with care, a well-written response can turn a negative into a positive for prospective families reading your reviews.

Turn Reviews Into a Competitive Advantage

Communities that make reviews part of their operating rhythm stand out. They show up higher in Google search results, earn more trust, and book more tours. It’s that simple.

Consistent reviews help:

  • Boost your SEO and visibility
  • Reassure prospective families
  • Reinforce a culture of transparency and excellence

Benchmark Your Community

Want to know how your community’s reviews compare to others in your region?

Use Quiltt’s [Google Review Benchmarking Tool] to:

  • See how your average rating and review count stacks up
  • Get personalized suggestions to grow your presence
  • Set realistic review goals based on local competition

[Benchmark Your Community] now and see where you stand!

Final Thoughts

You don’t need hundreds of reviews to make a big impact. Just a few thoughtful, authentic reviews each month can dramatically improve how your community appears online and how families perceive you.

Start with 3–5 per month. Build momentum. And remember: consistency is more powerful than perfection.

With the right tools and the right approach, your Google Reviews can become your community’s most valuable marketing asset.

Ready to take action? Benchmark Your Community today and set your review goals for next month.

Benchmark Your Community